Is My Idea Original?

This is a question I’m asked from time to time by inexperienced writers, who are—quite naturally—concerned that they’re not seen as copying another author or idea, or are afraid of having someone else copy theirs.

I say “quite naturally,” because in many areas of our life, we’re encouraged to be unique, original in our thinking and accomplishments, to claim ideas as our own, and somehow that is proof of intrinsic value.

However, there are several reasons—not all of them obvious—why presenting your book as unique, or going to great lengths to write something that has no existing equivalent, is not only not necessary, it can actually work against you.

Copyright Issues.

Let’s get this out of the way first of all. It’s not possible to copyright a story idea. It’s not even possible to copyright a book title.

Too often, new writers are loath to send their material to an editor or an agent because they’re afraid they’ll steal their idea. Trust me when I say this is a non issue. No agent is interested in taking your idea and executing it themselves. The same goes for a publisher. Asking a professional reader of any kind to sign an NDA is the kiss of death. The exception is if you’re a super-famous celebrity writing a tell-all memoir.

And don’t freak out if there are other books with the same or similar title to yours. It’s a good idea not to choose the same title as a book in your genre so you don’t confuse readers. But otherwise, it’s fine.

Publishers Don’t Like Unique.

If you hope to query your book for traditional publishing, it had better not be one of a kind. That’s because a publisher’s number-one concern is whether there’s an audience, a readership, for your book. They want tried and true. Known quantities. (They want great books and unique voices, but that’s different from a unique idea.)

That’s why query letters and pitches always include some language like, readers who enjoyed X will love my book, or think Xpopularbook meets Ypopularbook.

What will make your book stand out is not what you write so much as how you write it.

That said, I want to say a word or two about the idea of “high concept” stories. The Wikipedia entry defines it like this:

High concept is a type of artistic work that can be easily pitched with a succinctly stated premise.

Notice the word “unique” does not occur. Some high concept stories have elements that make them stand out against others in the same vein (think Hunger Games), but they also have elements that place them securely in a tradition or genre that means they will appeal to an established audience.

Execution Is Everything.

Sticking with Hunger Games for a moment, if  Suzanne Collins wasn’t such a great writer, the books might not have captured the imagination as they did.

It may seem an obvious point, but a writer has to pay off the interest in a particular story by writing something a reader can’t put down.

Quite honestly, in my view, it boils down to the characters. Creating characters that readers connect with, care about, are willing to accompany through their harrowing internal and external journeys is job number one for every writer.

There’s nothing new under the sun. Everything is new under the sun.

Both are true. Only you can write the book you will write. But chances are, there are other stories out there that tread the same or similar ground. And that’s fine.

In the end, the only thing you can do is commit to your idea and then work to write your book as well as you can. Sometimes that will involve working with a coach to keep you motivated and guide you through the ups and downs.

However you prefer to work, you can always reach out to me for a no-obligation discussion about your book, and how I might be able to help you.

Just don’t ask me to sign an NDA…

Follow me wherever you like to hang out!

Related Posts

Write What You Don’t Know

Write What You Don’t Know

This is, of course, the opposite advice than is often given to young writers. But it occurred to me from a chance comment by someone on my email list that this is exactly what I do—in a way. It's not that I write from ignorance, exactly. Perhaps it would be better to...

read more
Fishermans Cowl

Fishermans Cowl

Cast on 28 stitches. Size 19 needles. Knit one row.  I had to throw so much yarn away before I moved, thanks to the moths. Alpacas and merinos that would have felt soft and warm as they slipped through my fingers and grew row by row into something, anything. Blues and...

read more
Books you have to write

Books you have to write

The peculiar thing about writing a book is that sometimes you don’t know where the idea for it came from. Other times you can trace it exactly to something you saw, heard, read, researched, etc. But whatever spawned the idea, something about it made you feel as if you...

read more
The Pleasures of Reading Together

The Pleasures of Reading Together

I moved into an apartment in an old mill building in Biddeford, Maine in February of this year. Although I have a daughter, grandsons, and a brother and his family who live in Portland (twenty minutes away), I knew no one in this town. I stayed in touch, of course,...

read more
Nothing Is the Same

Nothing Is the Same

My Life Changed. But I Still Have a Book Coming Out. I knew something was wrong with him almost a year ago, but I didn’t know how wrong. He’d seen me through nearly eleven book launches, was always there for the triumphs and the disappointments. He read my books, he...

read more



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *